I am not saying i'd leave the game, but seriously...it just seems wrong to have mortals who can judge your soul and have control over soul hits and what not. council or whatever, i'd stop playing blasword and play another char. thats not my call against it, its just what i'd do. its like rewriting something that a character's entire life is based on.

Vidumavi exclaims, "Wait!"
Vidumavi points at you.
Vidumavi exclaims, "Your that Blasword guy!"
>nod vid
You nod to Vidumavi.
Vidumavi exclaims, "You are the bomb!"

What comes around goes around my friends. I kinda hope this idea flies, if only for the IC conflicts it will surely drive. I, for one, am highly motivated to participate in the afronts my character is sure to be victim of, at the hand of this player based council. It will be interesting to see how the 'real' Paladins act and behave.