For next year: Anloral pins are always a great buy. Prayer mats. Shield of Light scrolls (they change the tap/look of your shield, purely cosmetic but fun).
I'd actually stay away from the 2he/2hb weapons. They're fairly heavy and the stats aren't great. High carbon steel is better, lighter, and cheaper.
Water containers if you want an interesting one, in a few different shops. I think there was an incense holder this year too?
